"Base deficit is the metabolic component": Unlike bicarbonate, which can be affected by acute respiratory changes, base excess/deficit isolates the metabolic component of acid-base disorders. This makes it invaluable for assessing the true metabolic status in patients with respiratory derangements.
"BD >6 in trauma = worse outcomes": In trauma patients, a base deficit greater than 6 mEq/L on arrival is a critical threshold associated with significantly increased mortality, need for massive transfusion, and risk of complications. This should trigger aggressive resuscitation and early activation of massive transfusion protocols.
Independent of PaCO2: Base excess remains relatively stable despite acute changes in ventilation. If a patient hyperventilates (low PaCO2), the base excess won't change acutely, whereas bicarbonate will appear falsely low. This is why base excess is more reliable in mixed disorders.
More reliable than HCO3 in mixed disorders: When trying to determine if a patient has a mixed metabolic and respiratory disorder, base excess provides a clearer picture of the metabolic component than bicarbonate alone. Calculate the delta-delta (change in anion gap vs change in bicarbonate) but use base excess to confirm.
Correlates with lactate in shock: In undifferentiated shock, base deficit and lactate should track together. If they don't, consider: (1) non-lactate causes of acidosis when base deficit is high but lactate is normal, or (2) type B lactic acidosis when lactate is high but base deficit is minimal.
Beware of over-resuscitation: Don't chase the base deficit with bicarbonate in most cases. Treat the underlying cause (restore perfusion in shock, insulin for DKA, dialysis for renal failure). Bicarbonate is rarely indicated and can worsen outcomes except in specific situations (severe acidosis with pH <7.1, hyperkalemia, tricyclic overdose).
Trending is key: A single base deficit value is useful, but serial measurements are far more valuable. In trauma and sepsis, failure to clear base deficit within 24 hours predicts higher mortality. Use base deficit clearance as a resuscitation endpoint alongside lactate clearance.
Saline-induced acidosis: Large-volume normal saline resuscitation (>2-3 L) can cause hyperchloremic metabolic acidosis with base deficit. This is usually benign and self-limiting but can confuse the clinical picture. Consider balanced crystalloids (LR, Plasma-Lyte) to avoid this issue.
Standard base excess (SBE) vs actual base excess: Most modern ABG machines report SBE, which normalizes for hemoglobin concentration. This is preferred for clinical decision-making. Actual base excess can be misleading in patients with severe anemia or polycythemia.
Chronic compensation vs acute disorder: In chronic respiratory disease, you'll see metabolic compensation. A COPD patient with chronic CO2 retention (PaCO2 60) may have a base excess of +8 - this is appropriate compensation, not a primary problem. Don't be fooled into thinking they have metabolic alkalosis.
References
- Kratz, A., Ferraro, M., Sluss, P. M., & Lewandrowski, K. B. (2004). Laboratory reference values. New England Journal of Medicine, 351, 1548-1564.
- Lee, M. (Ed.). (2009). Basic skills in interpreting laboratory data. Ashp.
- Farinde, A. (2021). Lab values, normal adult: Laboratory reference ranges in healthy adults. Medscape. https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/2172316-overview?form=fpf
- Nickson, C. (n.d.). Critical Care Compendium. Life in the Fast Lane • LITFL. https://litfl.com/ccc-critical-care-compendium/
- Farkas, Josh MD. (2015). Table of Contents - EMCrit Project. EMCrit Project. https://emcrit.org/ibcc/toc/